Australia's High Court hears constitutional challenge to under-16 social media ban
HouGarden Australia, 3 November — Online platform Reddit and advocacy group the Digital Freedom Project launched the challenge on Tuesday, arguing the policy goes too far in excluding young people from civic engagement. The Digital Freedom Project is also separately suing the eSafety commissioner, Australia's federal government body responsible for online safety. Although the two legal bids are distinct, the Australian High Court has joined them into a single special case because they rest on the same constitutional ground.
The ban came into effect in December last year. It requires social media platforms to take reasonable steps to prevent Australians under 16 from creating or keeping an account. Since then, nearly five million accounts have been blocked across the ten platforms captured by the legislation: Facebook, Instagram, Threads, Snapchat, X (formerly Twitter), TikTok, YouTube, Kick, Reddit and Twitch. Reddit is also suing the minister for communications and is seeking a separate declaration that it does not qualify as an 'age-restricted social media platform' under the legislation.
In written submissions to the Australian High Court, Reddit and the Digital Freedom Project argued there was a 'fundamental disconnect' between the law's stated intention and its practical effect. They said many under-16s had found ways to circumvent age-assurance technologies to retain or create new accounts, and that potentially harmful content remained accessible even without an account. The plaintiffs also argued there were 'obvious and compelling alternatives' that could have achieved parliament's purpose while placing a lesser burden on political communication.
Reddit's lawyers argued the law deprives young people of the ability to 'speak, interact, organise and reach domestic and global audiences quickly and inexpensively.' They added: 'The deprivation is profound where it is inflicted on a group that does not have the avenue of the ballot box.'
The Commonwealth is defending the law on the basis that social media platforms, driven by advertising revenue, are structured to prioritise user engagement and retention in ways that create risks of harm to children. Government lawyers told the court that the rules accompanying the policy are consultative, targeted and capable of being updated over time. The Commonwealth also argued that the implied freedom of political communication applies only to 'electors' — those eligible to vote — meaning any burden the ban places on that freedom is indirect, modest and justified.
Monash University constitutional law professor Luke Beck said the government had a strong case. 'It's very clear that the Commonwealth can regulate social media and online spaces,' he said. 'So this case is going to be useful in clarifying the extent to which the government can regulate.' Professor Beck added that even if the government lost, the policy might not be abandoned altogether. 'It may just be a technical breach that can be fixed with some tweaks in the legislation,' he said.
A government spokesperson said the administration would 'stand firm to protect young Australians from experiencing harm on social media' and declined to comment further while the matter was before the courts. Reddit's chief communications officer Adam Collins said the company shared the government's goal of protecting young people online 'but there are better, more effective ways to achieve it than the social media minimum age legislation.' Collins added: 'As we challenge this law in court, we'll continue to comply with it and advocate for more effective youth safety measures.'
The case has drawn international attention. The British-based Free Speech Union, US-founded internet industry trade association NetChoice and US non-profit Electronic Frontier Foundation have all applied to appear as amicus curiae, or friends of the court. State and territory attorneys-general have filed submissions in support of the Commonwealth. Hearings are scheduled to continue on Tuesday and Wednesday.


