ਸਾਂਝਾ ਕਰੋ

NSW shelves underquoting reforms hours before start date, citing falling prices

ਲੇਖਕ: Linda Hu
ਸਾਰThe New South Wales government has paused its new underquoting rules, which were due to start on 17 November. The state, whose capital is Sydney, says the laws were written for a rising market. Existing underquoting laws still apply, and the rules do not bind New Zealand buyers or sellers.

HouGarden Australia, 17 November — The NSW government, whose capital is Sydney, has paused its new underquoting reforms, which were due to start on 17 November. The decision was made on 16 November. The rules do not apply in New Zealand. New Zealand readers can use the episode only as a point of comparison.

Underquoting means an agent advertises a price below what the seller would truly accept, to attract buyers. The NSW laws were meant to curb that practice.

AGENT SHOWCASE LISTINGS

The legislation passed the NSW Parliament in June. NSW Fair Trading published detailed implementation guidance for the industry on 29 October. On 1 November the government confirmed the reforms would start on 17 November. On Monday 16 November, Premier Chris Minns stepped in, and by that evening the start date had been shelved.

Reports suggest the pause could last up to 12 months. That period has not been officially confirmed. It is also unclear whether the reforms will return in their current form or be reworked. The measures are suspended, not repealed, and no amended version has been announced.

Three main changes were due to begin. The first was mandatory price disclosure. Agents would have had to advertise a price or price range. That would have effectively ended "price on application" and "contact agent" listings in NSW.

The second was an explicit ban on advertising a property below a written offer the seller had rejected, or below the highest bid at a passed-in auction. A passed-in auction is one that fails to sell, known in Chinese-language media as a failed auction.

The third was a higher penalty. The maximum fine for underquoting would have risen from A$22,000 to A$110,000 or three times the agent's commission, whichever was higher.

The reforms also required price estimates to be based on the three most comparable recent sales. Advertising would have had to be updated within one business day of an estimate changing. All of these requirements are now on hold.

Minns said agents in his own electorate had told him the rules could stop sellers and agents from cutting an advertised price when a property was not attracting interest. He cited a 9.4% fall in property prices over the 12 months to October. That figure is the premier's, and it is not a national one. He said: "It's not the seller or the agent's fault if the price of real estate is dropping."

Minns also said the legislation "believed that the prices would always rise."

Anoulack Chanthivong, the Minister for Better Regulation and Fair Trading, had championed the reforms for well over a year. He said Parliament passed the laws "at a different time and in a different economic and housing market." He said the government would not proceed with implementation while households were under financial pressure. He said Fair Trading would work with consumer groups and the industry to refine the changes.

Tim James, the opposition's shadow Fair Trading minister, said the laws should have been designed to withstand a downturn from the start. He noted that "property prices move in cycles."

The rejected-offer rule drew the sharpest criticism. Take a seller who turned down a A$1.6 million offer in March. If rates rose and the market softened by September, the seller would have been locked into advertising at or above a figure that no longer matched the market. That would apply even if a job loss, divorce or death in the family forced a sale. Buyers who could afford the home at today's value might never see it in their search results.

Tim McKibbin, chief executive of the Real Estate Institute of NSW (REINSW), had made this argument for months. He warned that vendors are consumers too and that the rules risked trapping them. He welcomed the delay but criticised how it happened, saying "Governments should be stable." He claimed the minister had refused repeated requests to meet the institute.

McKibbin also noted that underquoting complaints tend to fall in downturns. Agents face pressure to quote realistically when buyers hold the upper hand. He said successive governments had spent 26 years toughening underquoting penalties without solving the problem.

The pause does not make underquoting legal. It has been illegal in NSW for years, and those laws still apply. Agents must have reasonable grounds for their estimated selling price, backed by comparable sales evidence. They must revise the estimate when new evidence shows it is no longer reasonable. That includes a genuine higher offer, so a version of the ban on advertising below a real, rejected offer already exists.

What has been paused is the additional, more prescriptive set of requirements and the much higher penalties. A government announcement is not necessarily the same as the legally operative regulations. Agents should check current requirements directly with NSW Fair Trading rather than rely on media reports.

Victoria offers a comparison. Melbourne has had comparable-sales-based Statements of Information since 2017. The state has now moved towards requiring auction reserves to be disclosed a week before auction day.

For buyers in NSW, little changes in practice. A price guide is a marketing figure set by the agent, not a valuation. Buyers should check recent comparable sales and set their own walk-away price before inspecting a property.

For sellers, the pause gives more room to cut the price if a campaign is not gaining traction. It is not permission to set an unrealistically low guide to generate interest.

For investors, the episode is a reminder that property markets move in cycles. Laws or strategies built on the assumption that prices only rise can be caught out. The effect on New Zealand-based buyers and sellers, including Chinese-New Zealand buyers, is minimal. It matters mainly to those buying or investing in Sydney.

网站声明原创声明: 本文系文章顶部作者原创采写,未获书面授权严禁转载! 在获授权前提下,转载必须在醒目位置注明本文出处和具体网页链接。对未注明而擅自转载者,将保留追究法律责任的权利。 评论规范: 1. 所有评论均以读者个人身份发表,并不代表后花园立场。 2. 不得使用任何肮脏和亵渎的措辞。 3. 不得进行人身攻击,不得公开或泄露他人隐私。 4. 不得发布侮辱或歧视任何种族、国籍、性别、地域、年龄、职业等方面的言论。 5. 不得在读者评论区散发广告讯息,不得大量转抄其他媒体的文章。 6. 不得煽动仇恨、暴力、歧视。 7. 不得以任何隐晦方式发布上述不当言论,包括但不限于使用字母、数字、代号、谐音、链接跳转等。 8. 后花园保留对违反上述规范的留言行为进一步处理的权力。
  
 
ਟਿੱਪਣੀ
ਕੋਡ
app logo

HouGarden ਐਪ ਡਾਊਨਲੋਡ ਕਰੋ

  • ਕਿਸੇ ਵੀ ਸਮੇਂ, ਕਿਤੇ ਵੀ ਪਸੰਦੀਦਾ ਜਾਇਦਾਦਾਂ ਲੱਭੋ ਅਤੇ ਸੇਵ ਕਰੋ

  • ਵਿਅਕਤੀਗਤ ਸੂਚਨਾਵਾਂ, ਨਵੀਨਤਮ ਅੱਪਡੇਟ ਸਭ ਤੋਂ ਪਹਿਲਾਂ ਪ੍ਰਾਪਤ ਕਰੋ

  • ਆਲ-ਇਨ-ਵਨ ਰੀਅਲ ਅਸਟੇਟ ਟੂਲ, ਘਰ ਖਰੀਦਣਾ ਅਤੇ ਵੇਚਣਾ ਆਸਾਨ ਬਣਾਓ