Luxon says final count could have taken five weeks without enrolment changes, but holds off on coalition talks
HouGarden New Zealand, 16 November — Voting in the election is over, but the final result has not been released. Nearly 400,000 special votes are not yet included in the count. Whether National can form a government depends on that final tally. No government has been formed and no formal negotiations have begun.
Luxon spoke to RNZ's Morning Report. He claimed it could have taken up to five weeks to count the vote if his Government had not changed enrolment rules. The five-week figure was his own hypothetical. It is not an Electoral Commission forecast.
Under the changes, people can no longer enrol and vote on the same day. Enrolments were also brought forward to before advance voting starts. Advance voting itself was not scrapped. Even so, the final result is still expected to take about three weeks in total, the same as at the last election. The final results are due in less than two weeks.
Luxon said the Electoral Commission's independence was important for democracy, but "I do struggle to understand why it takes so long to count". He pointed to the United States. "I've watched US midterm elections with tens of millions of people voting in states across the US and even in close races like Mississippi, you get a result turned around much quicker, so I think that's a legitimate question that we need to ask," he said.
He added: "The reality is: who knows, it could take them four or five weeks if we continued to see people saying, 'Look, I won't bother enrolling, I'll just do it on the day when I go cast my vote.'"
Luxon said the commission faced a "very challenging, very overwhelming" task. It had to carry out four component parts at once: getting people enrolled, running election day and the vote, and then doing the count. RNZ has sought comment from the Electoral Commission.
Luxon said he had spoken to ACT leader David Seymour, NZ First leader Winston Peters and Opportunity Party leader Qiulae Wong. He said formal negotiations would wait for the final count. "We really do need to respect our democracy and respect every vote that's been cast," he said.
Constitutional law expert Graeme Edgeler told RNZ last week that nothing prevents negotiations starting before the final count.
Luxon had consistently ruled out working with the Opportunity Party before election day. Asked why voters should trust him if he was going back on his word, he said New Zealanders would not want another election. "We went through this last week. We can go through it again another week," he said.
Interviewer Ingrid Hipkiss replied: "I haven't spoken to you in the last week." Luxon continued: "You want to know, so let me take you through it again, so look - on current numbers it's unlikely we actually need them to form a Government, as I've said ad nauseam... if the specials come back, and if for example there's a hung Parliament... Kiwis wouldn't thank us for going back to the polls."
A hung Parliament is one in which no single party or bloc holds a majority.
He said the campaign had left him with a clear takeaway. "One of my takeaways from the election campaign, and actually even you saw it in the debates, was that Kiwis want a lot more cross-party collaboration... it's important that I find areas of common ground with all parties, if possible."
Asked whether his rule-out had changed, Luxon said the idea that the current coalition parties would need Opportunity was "hypothetical". He pointed to National's work with Labour on modern slavery laws and a social media ban. "All political leaders should try and put politics aside and find the common ground," he said.
Luxon insisted throughout the campaign that Nicola Willis would be finance minister. He said National holding that role was non-negotiable. "Yes, I've talked to that before," he said.
Seymour said last week it was "no longer tenable" for National to demand the portfolio. Hipkiss asked whether Luxon had discussed it further with him. Luxon said: "Look, to be honest Ingrid, you and I have spoken about this in the last week and we can talk about it again for this week, I'm a bit more focused on APEC [Asia-Pacific Economic Cooperation] and some other big things going down."
Hipkiss asked: "As opposed to forming the next Government?" Luxon replied: "Well, I am forming the next Government. I've just told you the process, which is that we're waiting for the votes to be counted, and I think if you're in my position, you'd understand that that's the right position to be in."
Luxon will attend APEC in China on Wednesday and Thursday this week. How the next government is made up will shape the direction of later policy, though no specific policies have been announced.
Luxon also responded to departing Speaker Gerry Brownlee, who said National's campaign had been too negative. Luxon said every party had campaigned on positive policies and plans as well as "highlighting the contrast and the risk of the alternative".
Departing Banks Peninsula MP Vanessa Weenink said she would not miss public abuse. Some people told her they "hate" National, that the party had become too conservative and that the Treaty Principles Bill had hurt the country.
Luxon said Weenink held a "tough seat" that was historically a Labour seat. He called the idea that there were fewer liberals in National, after departures including Willis and Chris Bishop, "just absolute rubbish".
"You might have levelled that claim in 2020, but we had 20-plus new members come in in '23 that were from lots of diverse backgrounds. We've got another seven great new MPs that have come in this time as well from various backgrounds," he said.
"So, yeah, the National Party is always, the genius of it, is that it balances urban and rural, balances liberal and conservative, balances tradition and aspiration, and the thing that unites us is our values."

