Share

NSW delays underquoting reforms a day before start, as buyer agents warn problem will return when market recovers

Author: Linda Hu
SummaryThe New South Wales Government has postponed the first stage of its price-quoting reforms until 1 December 2027, one day before they were due to take effect. Buyer agents say shoppers remain exposed, while agents say the rule on rejected offers was unworkable in a falling market. New Zealand has no equivalent rules.

HouGarden Australia, 18 November — The New South Wales Government has shelved the first stage of its home price-quoting reforms, which were due to take effect on 17 November, after Premier Chris Minns intervened the day before. This is an Australian story about NSW, the state that includes Sydney. It does not apply to New Zealand, which has no equivalent price-guide rules. Sellers and agents in New Zealand commonly use listings such as "price by negotiation" or "enquiries from buyers", and nothing in this decision means those rules are in place or coming here.

Underquoting is already illegal in NSW. The reforms were a tougher layer on top of the existing framework, designed to make prices more transparent and to increase penalties and oversight for agents who break the rules. The Labor government announced them in March and Parliament passed them in June.

AGENT SHOWCASE LISTINGS

Some measures are unaffected by the delay. They took effect on 29 June and include higher penalties for certain property industry offences and stronger enforcement and disciplinary powers for NSW Fair Trading.

The first stage, due on 17 November, dealt directly with how homes are advertised. Under the original plan, residential listings had to show a price or price range. Listings that gave no price, such as "price by negotiation", would be restricted. Agents also had to base the price on the three most comparable sales and keep detailed records.

Online advertising also had to change within one business day in two situations. One was when a seller had rejected a written offer because it was too low. The other was when an auction was passed in and a higher top bid had emerged. Agents could not keep advertising below those figures.

A separate requirement was due from February 2027. Agents would have had to supply a price guide statement explaining to buyers how the guide was reached.

Mr Minns stepped in the day before the first stage began, and the government announced the pause. The dispute centres on the rule that sellers cannot advertise below a written offer they have already rejected.

The government's concern is that the rule was designed when prices were rising, but Sydney's market is now falling. A seller may start with an expectation that is too high and reject an offer. If the market keeps falling over the following weeks, the agent might be unable to cut the advertised price, even though the seller is now willing to accept less.

Mr Minns said falling prices were not the fault of sellers or agents. He said the original rule could have consequences that were not anticipated, particularly for people who urgently need to sell.

NSW Fair Trading then confirmed that the new rules on price advertising, setting price guides, record keeping and price guide statements are all delayed to 1 December 2027. This is a postponement, not a repeal.

The current underquoting law remains in force. Agents must still ensure the estimated selling price is reasonable and update it when the original estimate is no longer reasonable. They also cannot advertise below the estimated price in the agency agreement.

Buyer agent Paul Mulligan called on the government to restore the original timetable and close the gap before interest rates fall and the market becomes active again. He said buyers could still face misleading price guides, and could still pay for building and pest inspections on homes they cannot afford.

Sydney prices are still falling, so underquoting may not be a prominent problem in the short term. Underquoting means advertising a property well below the agent's reasonable estimate of its selling price, in order to attract more buyers and bidding. It tends to become more contentious in fast-rising markets.

Mr Mulligan pointed to forecasts from institutions such as the Commonwealth Bank that rates could start to fall from August next year. Those are forecasts, not certainties. He said buyers could be exposed again when the market recovers.

"We'll be back to the underquoting problem," he said. "Buyers will keep losing out because of it, and that is exactly why we have spent the past five years pushing for more transparency. While the reforms are in limbo, consumers will still be affected."

The key stalled change stops sellers advertising at a lower price after rejecting a higher offer. For example, a seller wants A$1.3 million and has received but rejected a written offer of A$1.25 million. The seller could not then advertise the home at A$1.25 million or less.

NSW property industry figures welcomed the pause, saying the rule was unworkable. Laing + Simmons chief executive Leanne Pilkington said: "There must be a mechanism for homeowners to adjust the price."

"If they later genuinely become willing to accept less, they should be able to re-adjust the advertised price. Especially in a market like this one, where prices are falling quickly, sellers often need time to accept market reality," she said.

Anoulack Chanthivong, the NSW minister responsible for better regulation and fair trading, said the reforms were passed in "a different market environment". Explaining the pause on Tuesday, he said: "These rules were introduced because underquoting was so widespread."

"But since then we have heard a lot of concern that, in the current market, these laws could have some unintended consequences. We will consult further with consumer groups and industry to strike a balance between protecting home buyers and making sure more people can buy a home," he said.

NSW opposition leader Kellie Sloane criticised the sudden change. She accused the Minns government and Mr Chanthivong of failing to resolve the problems before the policy was introduced, and of pulling it back at the last minute only after public criticism.

Ms Pilkington said she still supports the other transparency measures, such as clearer price guides or ranges and keeping the pricing evidence. She said the disputed rule has a "very simple" fix.

"Our suggestion is that owners simply provide a written statement explaining why circumstances have changed, for example 'my situation has changed for certain reasons', or 'we are now resetting our expectations based on market feedback'," she said. She believes this would keep the limits on underquoting while giving sellers reasonable room to adjust when the market moves.

The NSW approach is similar to consumer protections recently introduced in Victoria. These include requiring sellers to disclose the reserve price at least seven days before an auction or fixed sale deadline.

Victoria holds a state election in 11 days, and those rules could be changed again. Toby Balazs, chief executive of the Real Estate Institute of Victoria, said that if the Liberals win and form government, he hopes the seven-day reserve disclosure rule, introduced this year by the Labor government, will be scrapped.

The delay is mainly relevant to people buying in Sydney, including cross-border investors and buyers looking at NSW property. It has no direct effect on property transactions in New Zealand.

网站声明原创声明: 本文系文章顶部作者原创采写,未获书面授权严禁转载! 在获授权前提下,转载必须在醒目位置注明本文出处和具体网页链接。对未注明而擅自转载者,将保留追究法律责任的权利。 评论规范: 1. 所有评论均以读者个人身份发表,并不代表后花园立场。 2. 不得使用任何肮脏和亵渎的措辞。 3. 不得进行人身攻击,不得公开或泄露他人隐私。 4. 不得发布侮辱或歧视任何种族、国籍、性别、地域、年龄、职业等方面的言论。 5. 不得在读者评论区散发广告讯息,不得大量转抄其他媒体的文章。 6. 不得煽动仇恨、暴力、歧视。 7. 不得以任何隐晦方式发布上述不当言论,包括但不限于使用字母、数字、代号、谐音、链接跳转等。 8. 后花园保留对违反上述规范的留言行为进一步处理的权力。
  
 
Comment
Verification Code
app logo

Get the HouGarden app

  • Search and save homes you love

  • Get instant alerts on property updates

  • All your property tools in one place